18-11-2011, 11:42 PM | #21 |
Senior Member
Sub Adult
|
Well I'm going to overwinter this year (spur thighed tort, 18 months old) and for the last 6 weeks I have introduced 1 day a week no feeding and no UVB. And for the last 2 weeks I have increased this to 2 days.
Marley still wakes up and is active. He moves around the table all day, but is not on a mission looking for food, he is slower and calmer. He always has fresh water and still drinks on the non feeding days. His weight gain has slowed during this time. There are cooler/rainy/overcast days in their natural habitat and they don't do much at all, and I think with a long winter on a tort table it is better to contol conditions rather than have a really active tort and have to limit food. Just my thoughts
__________________
... Be young, be foolish, but be happy... Life is too short to worry about unimportant things. Reach for the sky, touch your star, and then you find your dream... TheTams - 1965
Last edited by Anita Sayles; 19-11-2011 at 12:01 PM. Reason: Edit, sorry posted late last night and got the dates wrong... |
20-11-2011, 11:25 PM | #22 | |
Member
Incubating
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Somerset
Posts: 216
|
Hibernation
[SIZE="3"][SIZE="4"][SIZE="5"]
Quote:
Whilst I am a long term Chelonia keeper and have kept and hibernated tortoises in wild condition in USA I am mostly a turtle keeper and I write from that perspective. Ernst and Lovich - Turtles of the United States and Canada second edition refers to winter dormancy as hibernation for both tortoises and turtles. Donald C.Jackson also uses the term hibernation in his many papers and also in his recent book "Life in a Shell" which is much recommended to all. The Wiki extract quoted is correct but the section on brumation cites the Bearded Dragon as an example. The example does however have its limitations and does not consider other forms of reptile life such as turtles and the crocodilians. A few of us are trying to get a consensus on this subject and I offer this as a working definition. Cooling The temperature is reduced for a period, usually co-incident with winter. The animal reduces activity and feeding may cease, but it does not necessarily go into an extended, torpid state Brumation The animal becomes torpid for a period which may last weeks and is often co-incident with winter. Hibernation The animal undertakes preparation and goes in to a torpid state for an extended period - duration in months. Physiological changes occur within the animal. Co-incident with winter and seen mostly in animals of northerly latitudes.. Aestivation The animal becomes torpid for a period of days or weeks. Co-incident with hotter weather. I agree that temperate or Mediterranean climate tortoises in their winter conditions seem to go into a brumation state but Ill come back to this. Torts and turtles have a liver that forms about 4% of body mass, this, bodily fluids and their muscles store huge quantities of glycogen which is used as an energy reserve for the winter. It's commonly thought that fat is the energy store but fat cannot be metabolised without oxygen. A recent paper has shown that with lower temperatures less energy is consumed thus less glycogen is used and less oxygen is required. There is a significant difference of energy usage between 10c and 3c of at least 20%. This will be true for tortoises also. Turtles deliberately seek out the colder water to reduce their metabolic rate and hence oxygen and glycogen use. This is particularly important for the pond dwellers, it will be remembered that up north winters can last many months so any energy saved can be reserved for the first days of spring. In addition in anoxic conditions glycogen is used significantly faster so lactic acid is produced faster. These animals actively seek out the coldest water with the highest oxygen content for overwintering. Stories are often told about turtles moving about under the ice, now we have a reason. In order to survive this, the animals have developed particular strategies that require physiological changes. Many turtles, in particular the northern pond turtles, have the ability to utilise the calcium carbonate (CaCo3) within the shell. Their shell is about 40% of body mass and its calcium is used to buffer the lactic acid in the blood and raise the pH thus reducing the effect of acidosis. In addition the shell can sequester some of the acid and store it for disposal when oxygen becomes available again after the winter thaw. The build up of lactic acid can take days or weeks depending on the temperature and the level of anoxia in the water (caused by iced up ponds). The lactic acid in the blood and in the shell can take equally long to dispose of once conditions are better in spring. The calcium used must also be replaced so for females about to produce eggs this is a particularly hard time. Turtles also have the ability to manage the flow of blood to the lungs once oxygen is depleted and they have become anoxic. The above points illustrate the fact that these animals go through physiological changes and are therefore hibernating in the full sense of the meaning. I also keep my turtles in naturalistic conditions in the UK and despite them being in hibernation mode I still see them moving about seeking optimal conditions. This weirdly gets us back to the proposition made by Caledonia originally and drawing me to conclude that hibernation as defined is valid but in some species there is a geographical or season driven overlap with the state of brumation. Such animals would be the Painted Turtle, the Spotted Turtle and the Snapper, all of which will not need to hibernate in the southern states. That brings us back to the tortoises. My G.Aggassizii when they hibernated dug themselves in and did not move about, what's more they seemed covered in dirt. My T.Graeca also hibernate themselves deep into the soil where they stay for months. My box turtles do likewise and as it gets colder they do move downwards in the soil. So here's my question; if they are covered in soil where the heck do they get their oxygen from? Do they use glycogen in the same way as the pond turtles and buffer any resulting lactic acid with calcium carbonate from their shell? If we artificially "hibernate" them under human control are we forcing them into a brumation state where in real life they would be hibernating? As was stated by Bindi and with the same sentiment please correct or add or inform if you have more info. Rom |
|
20-11-2011, 11:58 PM | #23 |
Senior Member
Adult
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: West of Scotland
Posts: 4,226
|
Thats really interesting Rom. We have often discussed how mediterranean tortoises in natural conditions dig down quite far into the soil and are covered over in such a way as there must be hardly any air.
Many keepers say that their tortoises dig down deeper when it gets colder and in this way access soil which is less cold than the soil exposed to the air in a hard winter. I'm not totally clear on the differences between hibernation and brumation but thats not a criticism of your definitions.
__________________
Testudo Hermanni Hermanni (Corse) tortoises |
21-11-2011, 01:34 AM | #24 |
Senior Member
Adult
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 4,887
|
I read this article last year on the cellular changes that occur in T.Graeca before, during and after hibernation. It includes a reconfiguration of the cellular oxygen requirement during hibernation.
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/1...50008709355603 |
21-11-2011, 06:50 AM | #25 |
Senior Member
Adult
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Surrey
Posts: 2,094
|
as Romski has recommended, I too would commend the reading of Life in a shell, by Donald C Jackson. Furthermore, wouldn't it be great if one of the National Chelonia Groups or Herpetological societies were able to get Prof Jackson, to present a lecture here in the UK?
Perhaps, on the physiology of Chelonia. The topic has great interest and in particular, the adaption of these Vertebrate forms to the natural process of hibernation. |
21-11-2011, 09:08 AM | #26 |
Member
Incubating
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Somerset
Posts: 216
|
Hibernation
Whilst there seems to have been loads of work done on hibernating turts in the winters of USA (funding availability), there does not seem to have been the same level of investigation on temperate terestrial tortoises. As I scratch the surface of this I get to think that we still know bugger all about torts.
We in the hobby have, over time, developed hibernation strategies that work. We are still refining them with the use of refrigerators for example as we have learned that animals hibernated thus lose less weight (=less glycogen usage at colder temps) The wider use of the web has meant that the hobbyist now has access to the work done by scientists and we can start adding to their knowledge to paint a better and more informed husbandry picture. I think we are now moving from having knowledge of what works in order to hibernate these creatures to an understaning of why it works -and thats a good thing. Kirkie do you have a copy of the paper? The implication is that physical changes occur along similar lines that have been described by Jackson for turts. Another question; if they do have a capability for dealing with lack of oxygen, have a heart beat that slows to a beat a minute and bugger all matabolic rate then why open the fridge door every day? Rom |
21-11-2011, 10:09 AM | #27 |
Super Moderator
Adult
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Sunny Scotland
Posts: 21,512
|
Surely they will get their oxygen underground in the same way plants do? All the plants that die off in winter above ground but their roots under ground are still alive must be getting oxygen from the soil?
|
21-11-2011, 10:25 AM | #28 |
Senior Member
Adult
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 4,887
|
Hi Rom,
The link in my post above will take you to the study (a .PDF download is available from the link) http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/1...50008709355603 I can only assume that opening the fridge door regularly is akin to refreshing the air in an incubator. The release of CO2 buildup in a closed system though I see your point that very little is probably being produced. Perhaps it errs on the side of caution. I suppose we see "underground" as a claustrophobic environment but there must be airflow and oxygen replacement taking place. My own tortoises and box turtles bury deeply into soil to hibernate but it's not a closed system. An experiment that a dispassionate mind like Donald Jackson would relish (not a critisim of him, it needs the detatchment to get the results). On the "weight loss" in hibernation aspect, I've put this down to dehydration rather than "fat" or indeed glycogen use. Over the past few years I've modified the environment my tortoises hibernate it (a gradual drop down to hibernation temperatures, allowing the animals to dig into deep soil) and I now see very little change in body weight post hibernation. I'd assumed the cocooning in soil prevented a degree of fluid loss (the fabled 10% acceptable weight loss of the box/fridge method). I know other who allow their tortoises to dig into the substrate of greenhouses have recorded the same thing, no weight loss. |
21-11-2011, 10:41 AM | #29 |
Senior Member
Adult
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 4,887
|
I think the most interesting point is that the gradual lowering of the oxygen requirement is cued by peak high summer temperatures and continues even if the tortoise is not then presented with winter conditions. It appears to be unconnected to low temperature or day length/light levels.
Last edited by Kirkie; 21-11-2011 at 10:46 AM. |
21-11-2011, 10:46 AM | #30 | |
Super Moderator
Adult
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Sunny Scotland
Posts: 21,512
|
Many people refer to torts as hibernating but I am not convinced that they do simply because I've read so many differing articles on it. It has been referred to as hibernation, brumation and dormancy. My Koi carp used to 'hibernate' apparently but my other outdoor fish were described as just slowing down for winter. I have read lots of stuff on what hibernation actually means, some that only mammals truly hibernate, some that they are not truly hibernating if they move around and come out to eat on warmer days (as torts do) and some that animals are simply going through a period of dormancy.
There are plenty articles like this one below and plenty that claim that this isn't the case too. Quote:
Last edited by Alan1; 21-11-2011 at 10:50 AM. |
|
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests) | |
|
|